“The Floor Guide Three isn’t for everybody, however it’s a one-of-a-kind laptop computer that is a pleasure to make use of.”

  • Distinctive 2-in-1 design
  • Large, sharp show
  • Highly effective graphics
  • Nice video enhancing efficiency
  • Glorious keyboard
  • Restricted processor efficiency
  • Very overpriced
  • Lowered battery life

The Floor line has by no means been identified for energy. They’re units that beg to be held, performed with, and drawn on. Efficiency isn’t a weak point, however for many Floor units, it comes second to design.

That’s been an issue for the Floor Guide. It’s the one Floor product Microsoft usually touts as having “powerhouse efficiency” — significantly within the giant 15-inch mannequin.

The most recent model, the Floor Guide 3, doubles down on this efficiency promise with higher graphics through the Nvidia GTX 1660 Ti and up to date Intel processors. However don’t be fooled — the Floor Guide Three nonetheless doesn’t have the center of a real workstation laptop computer. Does that maintain it again?


Efficiency is the one main change within the new Floor Guide, so let’s begin there. The Floor Guide Three bumps up each its processor and GPU to the newest Intel and Nvidia silicon, respectively. On this case, it’s the 10th-gen Intel Core Ice Lake processors and the Nvidia GTX 1660 Ti. My evaluation unit got here with a Core i7, 16GB of RAM, and a 1TB SSD.

CPU efficiency by itself isn’t spectacular for a tool this huge. There’s one main purpose for this: It makes use of the identical 15-watt chip that seems in small laptops just like the Dell XPS 13, Floor Laptop computer 3, and HP Spectre x360 13. That is vital. Not solely is that much less energy than the CPUs in most 15-inch laptops, it additionally solely has 4 processing cores to work with. The Dell XPS 15, ThinkPad X1 Excessive, and 16-inch MacBook Professional all function as much as eight cores.

The distinction in core rely makes a large distinction in efficiency. Add 4 cores with a laptop computer just like the Dell XPS 15, and also you’ll see a 53% higher rating in Cinebench R20’s multi-core take a look at than the Floor Guide 3.

The 15-inch Floor Guide Three has an ace up its sleeve. Graphics.

It’s not that Microsoft is deliberately holding again efficiency. The Floor Guide Three has to include most of its elements — CPU, reminiscence, and extra — in its pill portion. All of it sits behind the display screen, like an iPad or a Floor Professional. As a lot as I need Microsoft to conjure some engineering magic and toss in a 45-watt processor, there are limitations inherent on this design.

However the 15-inch Floor Guide Three does have an ace up its sleeve: Graphics. It now makes use of the Nvidia GTX 1660 Ti, and it is available in all configurations. And as we’ll see, the Floor Guide Three is ready to use these graphics in a approach different laptops can’t.

I loaded up a 2-minute 4K video mission in Adobe Premiere and began rendering the clip to ProRes 422. To my shock, the Floor Guide Three completed the duty in simply 5 minutes and 25 seconds. That’s actually quick. Regardless of having 4 further cores, the XPS 15 solely beat it by 30 seconds in that very same rendering take a look at. Choices just like the MacBook Professional or Razer Blade aren’t even near this quick.

The Floor Guide Three is ready to max out the load to its CPU and GPU at 100% at many factors all through the render time. The system is ready to hand off the additional pressure on the processor to the graphics card. This isn’t attainable with a regular laptop computer the place these sizzling elements are all stuffed into the identical chassis. On the Floor Guide 3, the graphics card is positioned within the base, whereas the CPU and different elements are positioned behind the display screen.

Ironic, isn’t it? The identical purpose the Floor Guide Three is processor-capped can be what offers the graphics card a lot room to breath. The one catch (and it’s an enormous one) is the very fact this solely applies to software program able to utilizing the GPU. Demanding software program that may’t faucet into the GPU gained’t profit from the increase it may present.

yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7 - Microsoft Floor Guide 3 15 Evaluation: Graphics, Unleashed

After all, a strong graphics card has different makes use of. Although the Floor Guide Three is something however a gaming laptop computer, it shocked me with its gaming chops.

It posts a 33% enhance in 3DMark’s Time Spy take a look at over the Floor Guide 2, which used the GTX 1060. Whereas a laptop computer just like the XPS 15 has a way more highly effective processor, the GTX 1660 Ti helps the Floor Guide Three be a greater gaming laptop computer. With the decision set to 1080p and the graphics at Extremely, Battlefield V performed at a clean 60 frames per second. There’s not a lot level in going past that, because the Floor Guide 3’s show refreshes at 60Hz.

The Floor Guide Three was significantly spectacular in Murderer’s Creed Odyssey, a troublesome recreation that challenges even highly effective gaming PCs. Whereas the sport was practically unplayable on the XPS 15, the Floor Guide Three can deal with it even at Extremely Excessive settings at a mean of 48 frames per second. Microsoft even mounted the battery problem that saved the Floor Guide 2 from holding its cost whereas gaming.

Not all purposes are able to make the most of the GPU on this approach. You gained’t have the identical luck in Lightroom, and even video encoding software program like Handbrake is restricted to the CPU. The Floor Guide Three is painfully sluggish in these conditions. Even smaller laptops just like the Dell XPS 13 and the MacBook Professional 13-inch beat it out in video encoding, thanks to higher thermals or higher-wattage processors.

So sure, the Floor Guide 3 can be a strong laptop computer, relying on the duty at hand. It’s a surprisingly succesful video-editing machine, and even a good gaming laptop computer while you want it to be.

The Floor Guide Three as a pill

yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7 - Microsoft Floor Guide 3 15 Evaluation: Graphics, Unleashed

The Floor Guide Three stays an adventurous design, even for Microsoft.

It’s a 2-in-1 just like the Floor Professional, besides that the display screen attaches instantly into the “dynamic fulcrum hinge” on the bottom. With an amazingly tight connection, the pill portion plugs into the bottom to kind a laptop computer expertise with only a few compromises.

With the push of a perform key, the pill pulls off with relative ease. You may even reattach the pill backwards so it may be used for displays or watching movies. It’s an intuitive different to utilizing kickstands or magnets to carry the display screen up.

The brand new Floor Guide Three works similar to the unique launched 4 years in the past.

I do miss the pill kickstand, nevertheless. I usually use tablets within the kitchen whereas cooking or cleansing, which the Floor Professional or iPad are each good for. There’s no solution to prop up the Floor Guide Three with out reattaching it to the big base. The shortage of an adjustable kickstand additionally makes writing on the pill a bit clumsy. It’s most snug hooked up to the bottom backward, with the keyboard flipped round.

Within the period of the iPad Professional and Magic Keyboard, the Floor Guide 3’s answer isn’t the one recreation on the town. Regardless of the emphasis Microsoft places on the experimental design of its merchandise, the brand new Floor Guide Three works similar to the unique launched 4 years in the past.

yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7 - Microsoft Floor Guide 3 15 Evaluation: Graphics, Unleashed

The software program additionally feels frozen in time. Home windows 10 nonetheless lacks a sturdy, touch-ready app ecosystem and significant gesture assist to make the pill mode really feel something however supplemental. That’s extra forgivable right here than on the Floor Professional, however it rains on the parade of the spectacular pill {hardware}.

The pill itself weighs simply 1.eight kilos, which is a bit heavier than the 1.4-pound iPad Professional (12.9-inch). The full weight of the Floor Guide Three is a hefty 4.2 kilos, however for its measurement, the pill feels remarkably gentle.

It’s straightforward sufficient to carry in a single hand like a clipboard and use with the Floor Pen or scroll the online whereas lounging on the sofa. The stylus doesn’t come bundled in, sadly, and wasn’t included with my evaluation unit.

Battery life is the one main downside with pill mode. Solely a portion of the battery is obtainable in pill mode, as a result of the battery is cut up between the pill and keyboard dock. You may count on just a few hours of battery life from the pill alone — lengthy sufficient to observe a film in mattress, however not far more.

The Floor Guide Three as a laptop computer

yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7 - Microsoft Floor Guide 3 15 Evaluation: Graphics, Unleashed

Greater than the Floor Professional, the Floor Guide Three is supposed to be a laptop-first expertise.

Its obtuse hinge isn’t too noticeable with the laptop computer open, however it makes the machine thicker. At its thickest level, it’s 0.90 inches. That’s a tough squeeze in lots of backpacks. It’s in any other case a sturdy, exceptionally well-built laptop computer. Simply hold its measurement in thoughts before you purchase.

Like all Floor merchandise, the Floor Guide Three has a top-notch keyboard and touchpad. As a result of the keycaps sit above the keyboard deck, it’s a particularly tactile keyboard that replicates an exterior keyboard greater than most laptop computer keyboards. When you miss that clickity-clack really feel on trendy laptops, you’ll love typing on the Floor Guide 3.

Until you’re knowledgeable picture editor, you’ll completely get pleasure from this massive, crisp show.

The identical goes for the glass touchpad, which has a quiet click on mechanism and exact monitoring. The touchpad is giant sufficient, although I’d wish to see it expanded. The MacBook Professional 16 has a bigger trackpad, and even the brand new Dell XPS 15 has expanded the dimensions to make use of each millimeter of the out there house. There’s no purpose the Floor Guide 3’s couldn’t be bigger.

The audio system aren’t positioned within the base of the laptop computer, however within the pill itself. That makes for good positioning, with them pointed instantly towards your ears. They aren’t the loudest or boomiest audio system on the earth for watching motion pictures, although.

You undoubtedly gained’t complain concerning the ultra-sharp 3,240 x 2,160 show. It’s a stupendous, high-contrast display screen, and as lengthy you persist with the sRGB colour mode, it’s even colour correct. It’s not shiny sufficient to compete with the MacBook Professional, neither is the colour gamut huge sufficient. For all the things apart from skilled picture enhancing, nevertheless, you’ll completely get pleasure from this massive, crisp show.

yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7 - Microsoft Floor Guide 3 15 Evaluation: Graphics, Unleashed

As a result of the chassis hasn’t modified in 4 years, the Floor Guide Three sticks to an older set of ports: Two USB-A, a full-sized SD card slot, the Floor Join dock for energy, and a USB-C port. The shortage of Thunderbolt Three is a obtrusive omission. Microsoft continues to keep away from the high-powered, superfast port know-how that just about all its opponents use. As Dell strikes to 4 Thunderbolt Three ports on its XPS 15 and XPS 17, the Floor Guide 3’s choices are a bit stale.

Battery life is a key ingredient for the laptop computer expertise, and the Floor Guide 2 was a record-setter. Because of its two batteries — one behind the display screen and one within the base — it lasted for 20 hours in native video playback. The Floor Guide Three nonetheless has a whopping 82 watt-hours of juice, and but it’s battery life has been considerably diminished by greater than 50% in some checks.

In native video playback, it lasts 13 hours and 42 minutes, whereas it’s nearer to eight.5 hours in additional average internet shopping. It lasts me via the workday, however the big discount is sort of disappointing. I think a firmware replace might resolve the difficulty, however Microsoft hasn’t but responded with a proof.

Lastly, the value of the Floor Guide Three can’t be missed. The 15-inch mannequin begins at a hefty $2,400, although it comes with simply 256GB of SSD storage. Even the costly 16-inch MacBook Professional begins with twice the storage for a similar worth. If you’re dearer than a model that’s already criticized by most as being overpriced, you’re in hassle.

The one approach so as to add extra storage to the Floor Guide Three is to spend at further $400, which additionally bumps you as much as 32GB of RAM. Restricted configurations makes it exhausting to customise the Floor Guide Three precisely how you may want it.

Our take

The Microsoft Floor Guide Three stays a distinct segment laptop computer, particularly in its 15-inch kind. The value is loopy, and the mediocre processor limits the varieties of labor it excels at. Nonetheless, the spectacular graphics efficiency turns the Floor Guide Three right into a stable video-editing and gaming machine. The distinctive design stays its main draw, nevertheless,

Are there any options?

The closest different to the Floor Guide Three are the opposite Floor merchandise just like the Floor Professional 7, Floor Professional X, or Floor Laptop computer 3. The Floor Laptop computer Three is the one that additionally comes at this measurement, although it doesn’t provide a discrete graphics choice.

When you can provide up the pill expertise, the Dell XPS 15 and 16-inch MacBook Professional provide higher processor efficiency. The XPS can be less expensive.

How lengthy will it final?

The Floor Guide Three ought to final you various years. Due to its distinctive design, you gained’t have the ability to improve the reminiscence or storage by yourself. The Floor Guide Three comes with a 60-day return coverage and a yr of in-store technical assist, so so long as you reside close to a Microsoft Retailer. The guarantee is a regular restricted one-year contract.

Must you purchase it?

Sure. Because of some highly effective graphics, the Floor Guide Three is by far probably the most highly effective Floor machine ever made.

Editors’ Suggestions


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here